The Pattern #228: When the rain doesnt come.

The RBI won’t loosen the rule capping microfinance repayments at 50% of income. In drought-hit Marathwada, you can see why — farmers chased by recovery agents, one found dead over a ₹10,000 loan that became ₹70,000.

The Pattern #228: When the rain doesnt come.

Welcome to the 228th edition of The Pattern — a weekly newsletter on the latest in finance, technology, and the economy.

Last week gave us two views of the same problem, a few hundred kilometres apart.

On November 15, in Mumbai, RBI Deputy Governor Shirish Chandra Murmu stood in front of the microfinance industry and refused to loosen a rule about how much a poor household is allowed to borrow.

The same fortnight, in the drought-hit districts of Marathwada, recovery agents were at the doors of farmers who couldn’t repay what they already owed. One man in Nanded had borrowed ₹10,000 and was being chased for ₹70,000. He was later found dead inside the finance company’s office.

These are the same story at two altitudes. One is a policy argument about a ratio. The other is what the ratio is for.

What they were actually arguing about

The rule at the centre of the Mumbai half is the repayment cap. A microfinance household’s monthly loan repayments can’t exceed 50% of its monthly income. The industry wanted that eased — specifically, to leave the principal portion of certain loans out of the calculation, which would let lenders hand the same borrower a bigger loan.

Murmu said no. Fifty per cent is already a liberal threshold, he argued, and leaving principal out would understate how indebted a household really is. He plainly stated the exact thing he was worried about:borrowers taking bigger loans to repay older ones, and household incomes being overstated to qualify. A ₹10,000 loan that turns into a ₹70,000 demand is what that looks like after it’s run for a while.

We have seen this film before

I’ve been watching this sector long enough to find the Marathwada news horribly familiar. In 2010, Andhra Pradesh went through almost exactly this — aggressive lending, borrowers stacked with more debt than they could carry, recovery agents, a wave of suicides, and a sector that very nearly collapsed under the backlash. The rules Murmu is now defending, the income threshold and the repayment cap, are the children of that crisis. They weren’t drawn up in a seminar. They were written after the worst had already happened, to make sure it didn’t happen the same way again.

So when Murmu holds the line on the cap, he’s defending a safeguard that was written the last time this went wrong — which is reason enough to take the refusal seriously, rather than read it as the RBI being inflexible.

The shock the cap was built for

Murmu’s whole case rested on a simple point: low-income households carry thin cushions and are badly exposed to economic shocks. The cap is the buffer against the bad year.

The bad year is here. Maharashtra has declared 304 of its 358 talukas drought-hit after a failed Kharif season. Microfinance runs on the assumption of steady weekly income, and a drought removes the income while leaving the repayment schedule exactly where it was. When that gap opens, the recovery machinery moves in — in Latur, that has meant harassment complaints, seized property, and allegedly forged court orders.

Why the book was so exposed

Part of the reason sits in how lenders have been operating. Even as the overall microfinance portfolio shrank about 5% over the year to ₹3.28 lakh crore, serving 6.4 crore borrowers, the average loan size climbed 17.5% to around ₹63,000, with lenders steadily favouring bigger loans to borrowers who already have a repayment record. In a normal year that’s good underwriting. It also means more rupees of obligation sitting on each household when the rain fails.

Where this leaves us

The state has stepped into the space the rulebook couldn’t hold. Deputy CM Shinde has warned that lenders will face murder charges if a drought-hit farmer dies by suicide due to harassment, and the Maharashtra government has asked the RBI directly to stop forcible recovery. Once a Deputy Chief Minister is reaching for homicide law, the prudential system has already been overtaken on the ground.

So an argument over whether to exclude principal from a repayment ratio turns out to matter a great deal, dull as it sounds from the outside. That 50% line is the distance between a household that can ride out a bad season and one that opens the door to a recovery agent. Getting credit into people’s hands was always the easy part. The real test is whether the system holds when the rain doesn’t come — and this year, in Marathwada, it hasn’t.

Until next week,

Mayank

If this was useful, forward it to one person who works on bank borrowings at an NBFC, or on priority sector compliance at a bank.

Reading list


Views are personal and do not reflect those of FinBox or its promoters.

Still exploring this topic?
Get instant, cited answers from the FinBox lending knowledge base

Stay current

Get research like this in your inbox.

Join 5,000+ lending professionals who read FinBox's research on credit infrastructure, underwriting, and embedded finance.

Subscribe free
Mayank Jain
Mayank Jain

Head - Marketing and Content